Extract from the Register of European Patents

EP About this file: EP2912149

EP2912149 - USE OF QUATERNISED AMMONIUM SALTS OF HYDROCARBYL EPOXIDES AS ADDITIVES IN FUELS AND LUBRICANTS [Right-click to bookmark this link]
Former [2015/36]QUATERNIZED AMMONIUM SALTS OF HYDROCARBYL EPOXIDES AND USE THEREOF AS ADDITIVES IN FUELS AND LUBRICANTS
[2017/02]
StatusPatent maintained as amended
Status updated on  22.11.2024
Database last updated on 28.03.2026
FormerThe patent has been granted
Status updated on  12.05.2017
FormerGrant of patent is intended
Status updated on  17.01.2017
Most recent event   Tooltip10.12.2024Change - representative 
Applicant(s)For all designated states
BASF SE
Carl-Bosch-Strasse 38
67056 Ludwigshafen am Rhein / DE
[2024/52]
Former [2017/24]For all designated states
BASF SE
Carl-Bosch-Strasse 38
67056 Ludwigshafen am Rhein / DE
Former [2015/36]For all designated states
BASF SE
67056 Ludwigshafen / DE
Inventor(s)01 / HANSCH, Markus
Mönchsgasse 10 A
67346 Speyer / DE
02 / BÖHNKE, Harald
Eichendorffstr. 19
68167 Mannheim / DE
03 / GRABARSE, Wolfgang
Torwiesenstr. 21
68163 Mannheim / DE
04 / KÖNIG, Hannah Maria
Wallonenstr. 10b
76297 Stutensee / DE
05 / LANGE, Arno
Oberes Gaistal 3b
67098 Bad Dürkheim / DE
06 / VÖLKEL, Ludwig
Carl-Bosch-Str. 18
67117 Limburgerhof / DE
 [2015/36]
Representative(s)BASF IP Association
BASF SE
GBI - Z078
67056 Ludwigshafen / DE
[N/P]
Former [2024/52]Meissner Bolte Partnerschaft mbB
Patentanwälte Rechtsanwälte
Postfach 86 06 24
81633 München / DE
Former [2017/24](deleted)
Former [2015/36]Reitstötter Kinzebach
Patentanwälte
Sternwartstrasse 4
81679 München / DE
Application number, filing date13780142.923.10.2013
[2015/36]
WO2013EP72169
Priority number, dateEP2012018953823.10.2012         Original published format: EP 12189538
[2015/36]
Filing languageDE
Procedural languageDE
PublicationType: A1 Application with search report
No.:WO2014064151
Date:01.05.2014
Language:DE
[2014/18]
Type: A1 Application with search report 
No.:EP2912149
Date:02.09.2015
Language:DE
The application published by WIPO in one of the EPO official languages on 01.05.2014 takes the place of the publication of the European patent application.
[2015/36]
Type: B1 Patent specification 
No.:EP2912149
Date:14.06.2017
Language:DE
[2017/24]
Type: B2 New European patent specification 
No.:EP2912149
Date:25.12.2024
Language:DE
[2024/52]
Search report(s)International search report - published on:EP01.05.2014
ClassificationIPC:C10L1/222, C07C209/20, C07C211/63
[2015/36]
CPC:
C10L1/2225 (EP,US); C07C215/08 (US); C07C213/04 (US);
C07C215/40 (EP,US); C07D207/04 (EP,US); C07D209/12 (EP,US);
C10L1/143 (EP,US); C10L1/22 (US); C10L1/232 (EP,US);
C10L1/2383 (EP,US); C10L10/04 (EP,US); C10L10/06 (EP,US);
C10M133/08 (EP,US); C10M133/44 (EP,US); C10M133/54 (EP,US);
C10M133/58 (EP,US); C10M141/06 (EP,US); C10M161/00 (EP,US);
C10L1/1881 (EP,US); C10L1/1888 (EP,US); C10L1/189 (EP,US);
C10L1/221 (US); C10L2200/0259 (US); C10L2270/023 (EP,US);
C10L2270/026 (EP,US); C10M2207/121 (EP,US); C10M2207/125 (EP,US);
C10M2207/144 (EP,US); C10M2207/18 (EP,US); C10M2215/042 (EP,US);
C10M2215/223 (EP,US); C10M2215/26 (EP,US); C10M2215/30 (EP,US);
C10N2030/04 (EP,US); C10N2040/253 (EP,US); C10N2040/255 (EP,US) (-)
Designated contracting statesAL,   AT,   BE,   BG,   CH,   CY,   CZ,   DE,   DK,   EE,   ES,   FI,   FR,   GB,   GR,   HR,   HU,   IE,   IS,   IT,   LI,   LT,   LU,   LV,   MC,   MK,   MT,   NL,   NO,   PL,   PT,   RO,   RS,   SE,   SI,   SK,   SM,   TR [2015/36]
TitleGerman:VERWENDUNG VON QUATERNISIERTEN AMMONIUMSALZE VON HYDROCARBYLEPOXIDEN ALS ADDITIVE IN KRAFT- UND SCHMIERSTOFFEN[2017/02]
English:USE OF QUATERNISED AMMONIUM SALTS OF HYDROCARBYL EPOXIDES AS ADDITIVES IN FUELS AND LUBRICANTS[2017/02]
French:UTILISATION DES SELS D'AMMONIUM QUATERNISÉS D'HYDROCARBYLÉPOXYDES COMME ADDITIF DE CARBURANT ET LUBRIFIANTS[2017/03]
Former [2015/36]QUATERNISIERTE AMMONIUMSALZE VON HYDROCARBYLEPOXIDEN UND DEREN VERWENDUNG ALS ADDITIVE IN KRAFT- UND SCHMIERSTOFFEN
Former [2015/36]QUATERNIZED AMMONIUM SALTS OF HYDROCARBYL EPOXIDES AND USE THEREOF AS ADDITIVES IN FUELS AND LUBRICANTS
Former [2015/36]SELS D'AMMONIUM QUATERNISÉS D'ÉPOXYDES HYDROCARBYLIQUES ET UTILISATION DESDITS SELS D'AMMONIUM QUATERNISÉS D'ÉPOXYDES HYDROCARBYLIQUES COMME ADDITIFS DE CARBURANTS ET DE LUBRIFIANTS
Entry into regional phase26.05.2015National basic fee paid 
26.05.2015Designation fee(s) paid 
26.05.2015Examination fee paid 
Examination procedure11.08.2014Request for preliminary examination filed
International Preliminary Examining Authority: EP
26.05.2015Examination requested  [2015/36]
22.09.2015Amendment by applicant (claims and/or description)
04.03.2016Despatch of a communication from the examining division (Time limit: M04)
25.05.2016Reply to a communication from the examining division
18.01.2017Communication of intention to grant the patent
04.05.2017Fee for grant paid
04.05.2017Fee for publishing/printing paid
04.05.2017Receipt of the translation of the claim(s)
Divisional application(s)The date of the Examining Division's first communication in respect of the earliest application for which a communication has been issued is  04.03.2016
Opposition(s)Opponent(s)01  14.03.2018  22.03.2018  ADMISSIBLE
INNOSPEC LIMITED
Innospec Manufacturing Park Oil Sites Road
Ellesmere Port, Cheshire CH65 4EY / GB
Opponent's representative
Appleyard Lees IP LLP, et al, et al
G Mill
Dean Clough Industrial Park
Halifax HX3 5AH / GB
 [N/P]
Former [2018/17]
Opponent(s)01  14.03.2018  22.03.2018  ADMISSIBLE
INNOSPEC LIMITED
Innospec Manufacturing Park Oil Sites Road
Ellesmere Port, Cheshire CH65 4EY / GB
Opponent's representative
Appleyard Lees IP LLP, et al, et al
15 Clare Road
Halifax HX1 2HY / GB
03.04.2018Invitation to proprietor to file observations on the notice of opposition
15.10.2018Reply of patent proprietor to notice(s) of opposition
09.07.2019Date of oral proceedings
24.09.2019Despatch of minutes of oral proceedings
28.04.2023Despatch of a communication from the opposition division (Time limit: M02)
23.06.2023Reply to a communication from the opposition division
10.08.2023Despatch of a communication from the opposition division (Time limit: M02)
18.08.2023Reply to a communication from the opposition division
22.11.2023Despatch of interlocutory decision in opposition
02.12.2023Legal effect of interlocutory decision in opposition
02.09.2024Despatch of communication that the patent will be maintained as amended
Appeal following opposition26.11.2019Appeal received No.  T3066/19
04.02.2020Statement of grounds filed
06.07.2022Result of appeal procedure: maintenance in amended form
21.07.2022Despatch of the decision of the Board of Appeal
22.11.2019Appeal received No.  T3066/19
22.01.2020Statement of grounds filed
06.07.2022Result of appeal procedure: maintenance in amended form
21.07.2022Despatch of the decision of the Board of Appeal
06.07.2022Date of oral proceedings
Fees paidRenewal fee
02.11.2015Renewal fee patent year 03
31.10.2016Renewal fee patent year 04
Opt-out from the exclusive  Tooltip
competence of the Unified
Patent Court
See the Register of the Unified Patent Court for opt-out data
Responsibility for the accuracy, completeness or quality of the data displayed under the link provided lies entirely with the Unified Patent Court.
Lapses during opposition  TooltipHU23.10.2013
AL14.06.2017
CY14.06.2017
CZ14.06.2017
DK14.06.2017
EE14.06.2017
ES14.06.2017
FI14.06.2017
HR14.06.2017
IT14.06.2017
LT14.06.2017
LV14.06.2017
MC14.06.2017
MK14.06.2017
MT14.06.2017
NL14.06.2017
PL14.06.2017
PT14.06.2017
RO14.06.2017
RS14.06.2017
SE14.06.2017
SI14.06.2017
SK14.06.2017
SM14.06.2017
TR14.06.2017
BG14.09.2017
NO14.09.2017
GR15.09.2017
IS14.10.2017
IE23.10.2017
LU23.10.2017
CH31.10.2017
LI31.10.2017
AT23.10.2018
[2020/34]
Former [2020/28]HU23.10.2013
CY14.06.2017
CZ14.06.2017
DK14.06.2017
EE14.06.2017
ES14.06.2017
FI14.06.2017
HR14.06.2017
IT14.06.2017
LT14.06.2017
LV14.06.2017
MC14.06.2017
MK14.06.2017
MT14.06.2017
NL14.06.2017
PL14.06.2017
PT14.06.2017
RO14.06.2017
RS14.06.2017
SE14.06.2017
SI14.06.2017
SK14.06.2017
SM14.06.2017
TR14.06.2017
BG14.09.2017
NO14.09.2017
GR15.09.2017
IS14.10.2017
IE23.10.2017
LU23.10.2017
CH31.10.2017
LI31.10.2017
AT23.10.2018
Former [2020/15]HU23.10.2013
CY14.06.2017
CZ14.06.2017
DK14.06.2017
EE14.06.2017
ES14.06.2017
FI14.06.2017
HR14.06.2017
IT14.06.2017
LT14.06.2017
LV14.06.2017
MC14.06.2017
MK14.06.2017
MT14.06.2017
NL14.06.2017
PL14.06.2017
RO14.06.2017
RS14.06.2017
SE14.06.2017
SI14.06.2017
SK14.06.2017
SM14.06.2017
TR14.06.2017
BG14.09.2017
NO14.09.2017
GR15.09.2017
IS14.10.2017
IE23.10.2017
LU23.10.2017
CH31.10.2017
LI31.10.2017
AT23.10.2018
Former [2020/10]HU23.10.2013
CY14.06.2017
CZ14.06.2017
DK14.06.2017
EE14.06.2017
ES14.06.2017
FI14.06.2017
HR14.06.2017
IT14.06.2017
LT14.06.2017
LV14.06.2017
MC14.06.2017
MK14.06.2017
MT14.06.2017
NL14.06.2017
PL14.06.2017
RO14.06.2017
RS14.06.2017
SE14.06.2017
SI14.06.2017
SK14.06.2017
SM14.06.2017
BG14.09.2017
NO14.09.2017
GR15.09.2017
IS14.10.2017
IE23.10.2017
LU23.10.2017
CH31.10.2017
LI31.10.2017
AT23.10.2018
Former [2019/51]HU23.10.2013
CY14.06.2017
CZ14.06.2017
DK14.06.2017
EE14.06.2017
ES14.06.2017
FI14.06.2017
HR14.06.2017
IT14.06.2017
LT14.06.2017
LV14.06.2017
MC14.06.2017
MK14.06.2017
MT14.06.2017
NL14.06.2017
PL14.06.2017
RO14.06.2017
RS14.06.2017
SE14.06.2017
SI14.06.2017
SK14.06.2017
SM14.06.2017
BG14.09.2017
NO14.09.2017
GR15.09.2017
IS14.10.2017
IE23.10.2017
LU23.10.2017
CH31.10.2017
LI31.10.2017
Former [2019/47]HU23.10.2013
CY14.06.2017
CZ14.06.2017
DK14.06.2017
EE14.06.2017
ES14.06.2017
FI14.06.2017
HR14.06.2017
IT14.06.2017
LT14.06.2017
LV14.06.2017
MC14.06.2017
MT14.06.2017
NL14.06.2017
PL14.06.2017
RO14.06.2017
RS14.06.2017
SE14.06.2017
SI14.06.2017
SK14.06.2017
SM14.06.2017
BG14.09.2017
NO14.09.2017
GR15.09.2017
IS14.10.2017
IE23.10.2017
LU23.10.2017
CH31.10.2017
LI31.10.2017
Former [2019/31]HU23.10.2013
CZ14.06.2017
DK14.06.2017
EE14.06.2017
ES14.06.2017
FI14.06.2017
HR14.06.2017
IT14.06.2017
LT14.06.2017
LV14.06.2017
MC14.06.2017
MT14.06.2017
NL14.06.2017
PL14.06.2017
RO14.06.2017
RS14.06.2017
SE14.06.2017
SI14.06.2017
SK14.06.2017
SM14.06.2017
BG14.09.2017
NO14.09.2017
GR15.09.2017
IS14.10.2017
IE23.10.2017
LU23.10.2017
CH31.10.2017
LI31.10.2017
Former [2018/45]CZ14.06.2017
DK14.06.2017
EE14.06.2017
ES14.06.2017
FI14.06.2017
HR14.06.2017
IT14.06.2017
LT14.06.2017
LV14.06.2017
MC14.06.2017
MT14.06.2017
NL14.06.2017
PL14.06.2017
RO14.06.2017
RS14.06.2017
SE14.06.2017
SI14.06.2017
SK14.06.2017
SM14.06.2017
BG14.09.2017
NO14.09.2017
GR15.09.2017
IS14.10.2017
IE23.10.2017
LU23.10.2017
CH31.10.2017
LI31.10.2017
Former [2018/43]CZ14.06.2017
DK14.06.2017
EE14.06.2017
ES14.06.2017
FI14.06.2017
HR14.06.2017
IT14.06.2017
LT14.06.2017
LV14.06.2017
MC14.06.2017
MT14.06.2017
NL14.06.2017
PL14.06.2017
RO14.06.2017
RS14.06.2017
SE14.06.2017
SI14.06.2017
SK14.06.2017
SM14.06.2017
BG14.09.2017
NO14.09.2017
GR15.09.2017
IS14.10.2017
LU23.10.2017
CH31.10.2017
LI31.10.2017
Former [2018/40]CZ14.06.2017
DK14.06.2017
EE14.06.2017
ES14.06.2017
FI14.06.2017
HR14.06.2017
IT14.06.2017
LT14.06.2017
LV14.06.2017
MC14.06.2017
NL14.06.2017
PL14.06.2017
RO14.06.2017
RS14.06.2017
SE14.06.2017
SI14.06.2017
SK14.06.2017
SM14.06.2017
BG14.09.2017
NO14.09.2017
GR15.09.2017
IS14.10.2017
LU23.10.2017
CH31.10.2017
LI31.10.2017
Former [2018/36]CZ14.06.2017
DK14.06.2017
EE14.06.2017
ES14.06.2017
FI14.06.2017
HR14.06.2017
IT14.06.2017
LT14.06.2017
LV14.06.2017
MC14.06.2017
NL14.06.2017
PL14.06.2017
RO14.06.2017
RS14.06.2017
SE14.06.2017
SK14.06.2017
SM14.06.2017
BG14.09.2017
NO14.09.2017
GR15.09.2017
IS14.10.2017
LU23.10.2017
CH31.10.2017
LI31.10.2017
Former [2018/30]CZ14.06.2017
DK14.06.2017
EE14.06.2017
ES14.06.2017
FI14.06.2017
HR14.06.2017
IT14.06.2017
LT14.06.2017
LV14.06.2017
MC14.06.2017
NL14.06.2017
PL14.06.2017
RO14.06.2017
RS14.06.2017
SE14.06.2017
SK14.06.2017
SM14.06.2017
BG14.09.2017
NO14.09.2017
GR15.09.2017
IS14.10.2017
Former [2018/21]CZ14.06.2017
DK14.06.2017
EE14.06.2017
ES14.06.2017
FI14.06.2017
HR14.06.2017
IT14.06.2017
LT14.06.2017
LV14.06.2017
NL14.06.2017
PL14.06.2017
RO14.06.2017
RS14.06.2017
SE14.06.2017
SK14.06.2017
SM14.06.2017
BG14.09.2017
NO14.09.2017
GR15.09.2017
IS14.10.2017
Former [2018/11]CZ14.06.2017
EE14.06.2017
ES14.06.2017
FI14.06.2017
HR14.06.2017
IT14.06.2017
LT14.06.2017
LV14.06.2017
NL14.06.2017
PL14.06.2017
RO14.06.2017
RS14.06.2017
SE14.06.2017
SK14.06.2017
SM14.06.2017
BG14.09.2017
NO14.09.2017
GR15.09.2017
IS14.10.2017
Former [2018/10]CZ14.06.2017
EE14.06.2017
FI14.06.2017
HR14.06.2017
LT14.06.2017
LV14.06.2017
NL14.06.2017
RO14.06.2017
RS14.06.2017
SE14.06.2017
SK14.06.2017
BG14.09.2017
NO14.09.2017
GR15.09.2017
Former [2018/09]EE14.06.2017
FI14.06.2017
HR14.06.2017
LT14.06.2017
LV14.06.2017
NL14.06.2017
RS14.06.2017
SE14.06.2017
BG14.09.2017
NO14.09.2017
GR15.09.2017
Former [2017/52]FI14.06.2017
HR14.06.2017
LT14.06.2017
LV14.06.2017
NL14.06.2017
RS14.06.2017
SE14.06.2017
BG14.09.2017
NO14.09.2017
GR15.09.2017
Former [2017/50]FI14.06.2017
HR14.06.2017
LT14.06.2017
LV14.06.2017
RS14.06.2017
SE14.06.2017
BG14.09.2017
NO14.09.2017
GR15.09.2017
Former [2017/49]FI14.06.2017
HR14.06.2017
LT14.06.2017
NO14.09.2017
GR15.09.2017
Cited inInternational search[XAY] US4621141  (CHIBNIK SHELDON et al.) [X] 1-3,6-11,15 * column 3; examples 7-10; claims 1,2,4; table 1 *[A] 12-14 [Y] 4,5
 [YD] DE102005041789  (BASF AG et al.) [YD] 4,5 * example 2; claim 1 *
 [AD] WO2006135881  (LUBRIZOL CORP et al.) [AD] 1-15 * claims 1-5; table 5 *
ExaminationEP2604674
by applicantUS4248719
 US4171959
 EP2033945
 WO2006135881
 WO2008060888
 WO2007025700
 EP1422246
 EP0244616
 WO9424231
 WO9703946
 DE19620262
 WO9603367
 WO9603479
 EP0476485
 EP0307815
 WO8701126
 EP0639632
 EP0310875
 EP0356725
 EP0700985
 US4877416
 DE3838918
 EP0831141
 DE3826608
 DE4142241
 DE4309074
 EP0452328
 EP0548617
 DE10102913
 WO9929748
 WO2005054314
 WO2004035715
 EP0061895
 US4491455
 WO9318115
 EP0261957
 WO0044857
 WO9804656
 US6743266
 WO0047698
   SIENEL, G.; RIETH, R.; ROWBOTTOM, K. T., EPOXIDES. ULLMANN'S ENCYCLOPEDIA OF INDUSTRIAL CHEMISTRY, 2000
   KOCH, H.; MAWER, R. L.; IMMEL, W.: "Polybutenes. Ullmann's Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemistry", 2011
   JAMES L. WHITE; DONGMAN CHOI.: "Polyolefins: Processing, Structure Development, and Properties", 2004, HANSER
   N. A. PLATE; V. P. SHIBAEV: "Comb-Like Polymers. Structure and Properties", J. POLY. SCI. MACROMOLECULAR REVS., vol. 8, 1974, pages 117 - 253, XP009033606, DOI: doi:10.1002/pol.1974.230080103

DOI:   http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/pol.1974.230080103
   ULLMANN: "Ullmanns Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemistry, 6. Auflage,", article "Amines, aliphatic"
   "Ullmann' s Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemistry 5. Auflage,", vol. A12, pages: 617 FF
OppositionUS4621141
 DE102005041789
 WO2006135881
 EP2604674
 WO2013117616
 US2013118062
 WO2015011506
 WO2015011507
 WO2010101801
 WO2010096168
 WO2011110860
 US2012010112
 US2008060608
 WO2008027881
 US4621141
 DE102005041789
 WO2006135881
 EP2604674
 WO2013117616
 US2013118062
 WO2015011506
 WO2015011507
 WO2010101801
 WO2010096168
 WO2011110860
 US2012010112
 US2008060608
 WO2008027881
The EPO accepts no responsibility for the accuracy of data originating from other authorities; in particular, it does not guarantee that it is complete, up to date or fit for specific purposes.