EP1833852 - PROCESS FOR PREPARING LUBRICATING COMPOSITIONS [Right-click to bookmark this link] | |||
Former [2007/38] | PROCESS FOR PREPARING POLYMERS AND COMPOSITIONS THEREOF | ||
[2014/50] | Status | Opposition rejected Status updated on 16.09.2021 Database last updated on 09.09.2024 | |
Former | The patent has been granted Status updated on 14.11.2017 | Most recent event Tooltip | 17.09.2021 | Opposition rejected | published on 20.10.2021 [2021/42] | Applicant(s) | For all designated states The Lubrizol Corporation 29400 Lakeland Boulevard Wickliffe, OH 44092 / US | [2015/22] |
Former [2007/38] | For all designated states The Lubrizol Corporation 29400 Lakeland Boulevard Wickliffe, OH 44092 / US | Inventor(s) | 01 /
BAUM, Marina 29400 Lakeland Boulevard Wickliffe, OH 44092 / US | 02 /
SCHOBER, Bart 29400 Lakeland Boulevard Wickliffe, OH 44092 / US | 03 /
DAVIES, Mark P.O. Box 88 Belper, Derby DE56 1QN / GB | 04 /
VISGER, Daniel 29400 Lakeland Boulevard Wickliffe, OH 44092 / US | 05 /
JOHNSON, John R. 29400 Lakeland Boulevard Wickliffe, OH 44092 / US | [2011/04] |
Former [2007/38] | 01 /
BAUM, Marina 29400 Lakeland Boulevard Wickliffe, OH 44092 / US | ||
02 /
SCHOBER, Bart 29400 Lakeland Boulevard Wickliffe, OH 44092 / US | |||
03 /
DAVIES, Mark P.O. Box 88 Belper, Derby DE56 1QN / GB | |||
04 /
VISGER, Daniel 29400 Lakeland Boulevard Wickliffe, OH 44092 / US | Representative(s) | D Young & Co LLP 3 Noble Street London EC2V 7BQ / GB | [N/P] |
Former [2015/22] | Mallalieu, Catherine Louise D Young & Co LLP 120 Holborn London EC1N 2DY / GB | ||
Former [2013/01] | Mallalieu, Catherine Louise D Young & Co LLP 120 Holborn London EC1N 2DY / GB | ||
Former [2008/34] | Bradley, Josephine Mary D Young & Co 120 Holborn London EC1N 2DY / GB | ||
Former [2007/38] | Bradley, Josephine Mary D Young & Co 120 Holborn London EC1N 2DY / GB | Application number, filing date | 05812467.8 | 21.10.2005 | [2007/38] | WO2005US38138 | Priority number, date | US20040621745P | 25.10.2004 Original published format: US 621745 P | [2007/38] | Filing language | EN | Procedural language | EN | Publication | Type: | A1 Application with search report | No.: | WO2006047393 | Date: | 04.05.2006 | Language: | EN | [2006/18] | Type: | A1 Application with search report | No.: | EP1833852 | Date: | 19.09.2007 | Language: | EN | The application published by WIPO in one of the EPO official languages on 04.05.2006 takes the place of the publication of the European patent application. | [2007/38] | Type: | B1 Patent specification | No.: | EP1833852 | Date: | 27.05.2015 | Language: | EN | [2015/22] | Search report(s) | International search report - published on: | EP | 04.05.2006 | Classification | IPC: | C08L53/00, C10M177/00, C08F2/38, C08F293/00, C10M145/14 | [2014/50] | CPC: |
C08F2/38 (EP,US);
C10M145/14 (US);
C08F293/005 (EP,US);
C08L53/00 (EP,US);
C10M177/00 (EP,US);
C08F2438/03 (EP,US);
C10M2209/084 (EP,US);
C10M2217/023 (EP,US);
C10M2217/024 (EP,US);
C10M2217/028 (EP,US);
C10N2020/04 (EP,US);
C10N2020/073 (EP,US);
C10N2030/02 (EP,US);
C10N2030/04 (EP,US);
C10N2030/08 (EP,US);
C10N2030/68 (EP,US);
C10N2040/04 (EP,US);
C10N2040/042 (EP,US);
C10N2040/044 (EP,US);
C10N2040/08 (EP,US);
C10N2040/25 (EP,US);
C10N2070/00 (EP,US)
(-)
| C-Set: |
C08L53/00, C08L2666/02 (EP,US);
C08L53/00, C08L2666/04 (US,EP) |
Former IPC [2007/38] | C08F2/38, C08F293/00, C10M145/14 | Designated contracting states | AT, BE, BG, CH, CY, CZ, DE, DK, EE, ES, FI, FR, GB, GR, HU, IE, IS, IT, LI, LT, LU, LV, MC, NL, PL, PT, RO, SE, SI, SK, TR [2015/22] |
Former [2007/38] | AT, BE, BG, CH, CY, CZ, DE, DK, EE, ES, FI, FR, GB, GR, HU, IE, IS, IT, LI, LT, LU, LV, MC, NL, PL, PT, RO, SE, SI, SK, TR | Title | German: | VERFAHREN ZUR HERSTELLUNG VON SCHMIERMITTELZUSAMMENSETZUNGEN | [2014/50] | English: | PROCESS FOR PREPARING LUBRICATING COMPOSITIONS | [2014/50] | French: | PROCÉDÉ POUR L'OBTENTION DE COMPOSITIONS LUBRIFIANTES | [2015/03] |
Former [2007/38] | VERFAHREN ZUR HERSTELLUNG VON POLYMEREN UND ZUSAMMENSETZUNGEN DAVON | ||
Former [2007/38] | PROCESS FOR PREPARING POLYMERS AND COMPOSITIONS THEREOF | ||
Former [2007/38] | PROCEDE POUR PREPARER DES POLYMERES ET DES COMPOSITIONS DE POLYMERES | Entry into regional phase | 22.05.2007 | National basic fee paid | 22.05.2007 | Designation fee(s) paid | 22.05.2007 | Examination fee paid | Examination procedure | 17.08.2006 | Request for preliminary examination filed International Preliminary Examining Authority: EP | 16.05.2007 | Amendment by applicant (claims and/or description) | 22.05.2007 | Examination requested [2007/38] | 15.11.2007 | Despatch of a communication from the examining division (Time limit: M04) | 25.03.2008 | Reply to a communication from the examining division | 16.12.2008 | Despatch of a communication from the examining division (Time limit: M04) | 23.04.2009 | Reply to a communication from the examining division | 23.09.2009 | Observations by third parties | 22.02.2010 | Despatch of a communication from the examining division (Time limit: M06) | 13.10.2010 | Despatch of communication that the application is deemed to be withdrawn, reason: reply to the communication from the examining division not received in time | 20.12.2010 | Reply to a communication from the examining division | 25.01.2011 | Despatch of a communication from the examining division (Time limit: M04) | 25.05.2011 | Reply to a communication from the examining division | 08.03.2012 | Observations by third parties | 20.03.2012 | Despatch of a communication from the examining division (Time limit: M06) | 03.08.2012 | Observations by third parties | 28.09.2012 | Reply to a communication from the examining division | 03.07.2013 | Despatch of a communication from the examining division (Time limit: M04) | 16.09.2013 | Observations by third parties | 03.10.2013 | Reply to a communication from the examining division | 12.11.2013 | Observations by third parties | 27.11.2013 | Despatch of a communication from the examining division (Time limit: M04) | 18.12.2013 | Reply to a communication from the examining division | 21.01.2014 | Observations by third parties | 16.05.2014 | Despatch of a communication from the examining division (Time limit: M04) | 26.09.2014 | Reply to a communication from the examining division | 18.11.2014 | Observations by third parties | 07.01.2015 | Communication of intention to grant the patent | 17.04.2015 | Fee for grant paid | 17.04.2015 | Fee for publishing/printing paid | 17.04.2015 | Receipt of the translation of the claim(s) | Divisional application(s) | EP10010731.7 / EP2292668 | EP18195217.7 Application withdrawn : 28.09.2018 | EP19160399.2 / EP3575332 | The date of the Examining Division's first communication in respect of the earliest application for which a communication has been issued is 15.11.2007 | Opposition(s) | Opponent(s) | 01
26.02.2016
02.03.2016
ADMISSIBLE New Market Services Corporation 330 South Fourth Street Richmond, VA 23219 / US Opponent's representative SSM Sandmair Patentanwälte Rechtsanwalt Partnerschaft mbB Joseph-Wild-Straße 20 81829 München / DE | [N/P] |
Former [2016/14] | |||
Opponent(s) | 01
26.02.2016
02.03.2016
ADMISSIBLE New Market Services Corporation 330 South Forth Street Richmond, VA 23219 / US Opponent's representative Schwabe - Sandmair - Marx Patentanwälte Stuntzstraße 16 81677 München / DE | 01.04.2016 | Invitation to proprietor to file observations on the notice of opposition | 10.08.2016 | Reply of patent proprietor to notice(s) of opposition | 17.10.2017 | Date of oral proceedings | 15.11.2017 | Despatch of minutes of oral proceedings | 15.11.2017 | Despatch of communication that the patent will be revoked | 09.06.2021 | Legal effect of rejection of opposition [2021/42] | 09.09.2021 | Date of despatch of rejection of opposition | Appeal following opposition | 15.01.2018 | Appeal received No. T0169/18 | 26.03.2018 | Statement of grounds filed | 09.06.2021 | Result of appeal procedure: maintenance in unamended form | 09.09.2021 | Despatch of the decision of the Board of Appeal | 09.06.2021 | Date of oral proceedings | Request for further processing for: | The application is deemed to be withdrawn due to failure to reply to the examination report | 13.12.2010 | Request for further processing filed | 13.12.2010 | Full payment received (date of receipt of payment) Request granted | 29.12.2010 | Decision despatched | Fees paid | Renewal fee | 29.10.2007 | Renewal fee patent year 03 | 27.10.2008 | Renewal fee patent year 04 | 26.10.2009 | Renewal fee patent year 05 | 25.10.2010 | Renewal fee patent year 06 | 25.10.2011 | Renewal fee patent year 07 | 25.10.2012 | Renewal fee patent year 08 | 28.10.2013 | Renewal fee patent year 09 | 27.10.2014 | Renewal fee patent year 10 |
Opt-out from the exclusive Tooltip competence of the Unified Patent Court | See the Register of the Unified Patent Court for opt-out data | ||
Responsibility for the accuracy, completeness or quality of the data displayed under the link provided lies entirely with the Unified Patent Court. | Lapses during opposition Tooltip | HU | 21.10.2005 | AT | 27.05.2015 | CY | 27.05.2015 | CZ | 27.05.2015 | DK | 27.05.2015 | EE | 27.05.2015 | FI | 27.05.2015 | LT | 27.05.2015 | LV | 27.05.2015 | MC | 27.05.2015 | PL | 27.05.2015 | RO | 27.05.2015 | SE | 27.05.2015 | SI | 27.05.2015 | SK | 27.05.2015 | TR | 27.05.2015 | BG | 27.08.2015 | GR | 28.08.2015 | IS | 27.09.2015 | PT | 28.09.2015 | IE | 21.10.2015 | IT | 21.10.2015 | LU | 21.10.2015 | ES | 22.10.2015 | BE | 31.10.2015 | CH | 31.10.2015 | LI | 31.10.2015 | NL | 01.11.2015 | [2017/40] |
Former [2017/13] | AT | 27.05.2015 | |
CZ | 27.05.2015 | ||
DK | 27.05.2015 | ||
EE | 27.05.2015 | ||
FI | 27.05.2015 | ||
LT | 27.05.2015 | ||
LV | 27.05.2015 | ||
MC | 27.05.2015 | ||
PL | 27.05.2015 | ||
RO | 27.05.2015 | ||
SI | 27.05.2015 | ||
SK | 27.05.2015 | ||
BG | 27.08.2015 | ||
GR | 28.08.2015 | ||
IS | 27.09.2015 | ||
PT | 28.09.2015 | ||
IE | 21.10.2015 | ||
IT | 21.10.2015 | ||
LU | 21.10.2015 | ||
ES | 22.10.2015 | ||
CH | 31.10.2015 | ||
LI | 31.10.2015 | ||
NL | 01.11.2015 | ||
Former [2017/04] | AT | 27.05.2015 | |
CZ | 27.05.2015 | ||
DK | 27.05.2015 | ||
EE | 27.05.2015 | ||
FI | 27.05.2015 | ||
LT | 27.05.2015 | ||
LV | 27.05.2015 | ||
MC | 27.05.2015 | ||
PL | 27.05.2015 | ||
RO | 27.05.2015 | ||
SI | 27.05.2015 | ||
SK | 27.05.2015 | ||
BG | 27.08.2015 | ||
GR | 28.08.2015 | ||
IS | 27.09.2015 | ||
PT | 28.09.2015 | ||
IE | 21.10.2015 | ||
IT | 21.10.2015 | ||
LU | 21.10.2015 | ||
CH | 31.10.2015 | ||
LI | 31.10.2015 | ||
NL | 01.11.2015 | ||
Former [2016/45] | AT | 27.05.2015 | |
CZ | 27.05.2015 | ||
DK | 27.05.2015 | ||
EE | 27.05.2015 | ||
FI | 27.05.2015 | ||
LT | 27.05.2015 | ||
LV | 27.05.2015 | ||
MC | 27.05.2015 | ||
PL | 27.05.2015 | ||
RO | 27.05.2015 | ||
SI | 27.05.2015 | ||
SK | 27.05.2015 | ||
BG | 27.08.2015 | ||
GR | 28.08.2015 | ||
IS | 27.09.2015 | ||
PT | 28.09.2015 | ||
IE | 21.10.2015 | ||
LU | 21.10.2015 | ||
CH | 31.10.2015 | ||
LI | 31.10.2015 | ||
NL | 01.11.2015 | ||
Former [2016/40] | AT | 27.05.2015 | |
CZ | 27.05.2015 | ||
DK | 27.05.2015 | ||
EE | 27.05.2015 | ||
FI | 27.05.2015 | ||
LT | 27.05.2015 | ||
LV | 27.05.2015 | ||
MC | 27.05.2015 | ||
PL | 27.05.2015 | ||
RO | 27.05.2015 | ||
SI | 27.05.2015 | ||
SK | 27.05.2015 | ||
BG | 27.08.2015 | ||
GR | 28.08.2015 | ||
IS | 27.09.2015 | ||
PT | 28.09.2015 | ||
LU | 21.10.2015 | ||
CH | 31.10.2015 | ||
LI | 31.10.2015 | ||
NL | 01.11.2015 | ||
Former [2016/33] | AT | 27.05.2015 | |
CZ | 27.05.2015 | ||
DK | 27.05.2015 | ||
EE | 27.05.2015 | ||
FI | 27.05.2015 | ||
LT | 27.05.2015 | ||
LV | 27.05.2015 | ||
MC | 27.05.2015 | ||
PL | 27.05.2015 | ||
RO | 27.05.2015 | ||
SI | 27.05.2015 | ||
SK | 27.05.2015 | ||
BG | 27.08.2015 | ||
GR | 28.08.2015 | ||
IS | 27.09.2015 | ||
PT | 28.09.2015 | ||
LU | 21.10.2015 | ||
CH | 31.10.2015 | ||
LI | 31.10.2015 | ||
Former [2016/28] | AT | 27.05.2015 | |
CZ | 27.05.2015 | ||
DK | 27.05.2015 | ||
EE | 27.05.2015 | ||
FI | 27.05.2015 | ||
LT | 27.05.2015 | ||
LV | 27.05.2015 | ||
MC | 27.05.2015 | ||
PL | 27.05.2015 | ||
RO | 27.05.2015 | ||
SI | 27.05.2015 | ||
SK | 27.05.2015 | ||
BG | 27.08.2015 | ||
GR | 28.08.2015 | ||
IS | 27.09.2015 | ||
PT | 28.09.2015 | ||
LU | 21.10.2015 | ||
Former [2016/26] | AT | 27.05.2015 | |
CZ | 27.05.2015 | ||
DK | 27.05.2015 | ||
EE | 27.05.2015 | ||
FI | 27.05.2015 | ||
LT | 27.05.2015 | ||
LV | 27.05.2015 | ||
PL | 27.05.2015 | ||
RO | 27.05.2015 | ||
SI | 27.05.2015 | ||
SK | 27.05.2015 | ||
BG | 27.08.2015 | ||
GR | 28.08.2015 | ||
IS | 27.09.2015 | ||
PT | 28.09.2015 | ||
LU | 21.10.2015 | ||
Former [2016/24] | AT | 27.05.2015 | |
CZ | 27.05.2015 | ||
DK | 27.05.2015 | ||
EE | 27.05.2015 | ||
FI | 27.05.2015 | ||
LT | 27.05.2015 | ||
LV | 27.05.2015 | ||
PL | 27.05.2015 | ||
RO | 27.05.2015 | ||
SI | 27.05.2015 | ||
SK | 27.05.2015 | ||
BG | 27.08.2015 | ||
GR | 28.08.2015 | ||
IS | 27.09.2015 | ||
PT | 28.09.2015 | ||
Former [2016/10] | AT | 27.05.2015 | |
CZ | 27.05.2015 | ||
DK | 27.05.2015 | ||
EE | 27.05.2015 | ||
FI | 27.05.2015 | ||
LT | 27.05.2015 | ||
LV | 27.05.2015 | ||
PL | 27.05.2015 | ||
RO | 27.05.2015 | ||
SK | 27.05.2015 | ||
BG | 27.08.2015 | ||
GR | 28.08.2015 | ||
IS | 27.09.2015 | ||
PT | 28.09.2015 | ||
Former [2016/09] | AT | 27.05.2015 | |
DK | 27.05.2015 | ||
EE | 27.05.2015 | ||
FI | 27.05.2015 | ||
LT | 27.05.2015 | ||
LV | 27.05.2015 | ||
BG | 27.08.2015 | ||
GR | 28.08.2015 | ||
IS | 27.09.2015 | ||
PT | 28.09.2015 | ||
Former [2016/07] | AT | 27.05.2015 | |
DK | 27.05.2015 | ||
FI | 27.05.2015 | ||
LT | 27.05.2015 | ||
LV | 27.05.2015 | ||
BG | 27.08.2015 | ||
GR | 28.08.2015 | ||
IS | 27.09.2015 | ||
PT | 28.09.2015 | ||
Former [2015/51] | AT | 27.05.2015 | |
FI | 27.05.2015 | ||
LT | 27.05.2015 | ||
LV | 27.05.2015 | ||
BG | 27.08.2015 | ||
GR | 28.08.2015 | ||
IS | 27.09.2015 | ||
PT | 28.09.2015 | ||
Former [2015/50] | FI | 27.05.2015 | |
LT | 27.05.2015 | ||
LV | 27.05.2015 | ||
BG | 27.08.2015 | ||
GR | 28.08.2015 | ||
IS | 27.09.2015 | ||
PT | 28.09.2015 | ||
Former [2015/49] | FI | 27.05.2015 | |
LT | 27.05.2015 | ||
LV | 27.05.2015 | ||
GR | 28.08.2015 | ||
PT | 28.09.2015 | Cited in | International search | [X]US5552491 (MISHRA MUNMAYA K [US], et al) [X] 6,24-31 * column 3, line 19 - line 34; claim 1 *; | [X]US2004106732 (TSUJI RYOTARO [JP], et al) [X] 1-25 * claim 3 *; | [X]DE10314776 (ROHMAX ADDITIVES GMBH [DE]) [X] 1-31 * paragraph [0075] - paragraph [0076]; examples 2-4,and,6-8; claims 1-17 * * paragraph [0111] - paragraph [0116] * * paragraph [0125] *; | [PX]EP1533327 (ETH ZUERICH [CH]) [PX] 1-23,26-31* paragraph [0073] - paragraph [0077]; examples 1-5; claims 1-25 * | Examination | US5955405 | US6369162 | US2003139553 | WO2006047398 | - Krzysztof Matyjaszewski, Thomas. P. Davis, Handbook of radical polymerization, Wiley Interscience, (2002), pages 645 - 646 | - EZIO RIZZARDO AND SAN H. THANG ET AL., "Living free-radical polymerization by reversible addition-fragmentation chain transfer: The RAFT Process", MACROMOLECULES, (19980722), vol. 31, pages 5559 - 5562 | - Ch. Barner-Kowollik (ed.), Handbook of RAFT Polymerizaton, Weinheim, Wiley-VCH, (2008), pages 455 - 456, ISBN 978-3-527-31924-4 | - KYUNG-YOUL BAEK, MASAMI KAMIGAITO, MITSUO SAWAMOTO, "Core-functionalized star polymers by transition metal-catalyzed living radical polymerization. 1. Synthesis and characterization of star polymers with PMMA arms and amide cores", MACROMOLECULES, (20010922), vol. 34, pages 7629 - 7635 | - URL: http://www.lubrizol.com/viscositymodifiers/asteric/default.html | other | US5955405 | US6369162 | US2003139553 | WO2006047398 | - CHIEFARI J. ET AL, "LIVING FREE-RADICAL POLYMERIZATION BY REVERSIBLE ADDITION-FRAGMENTATION CHAIN TRANSFER: THE RAFT PROCESS.", MACROMOLECULES, (19980811), vol. 31, no. 16, pages 5559 - 5562, XP000771996 DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1021/ma9804951 | - "ASTERIC T/M VISCOSITY MODIFIERS", (20120101), pages 1 - 2, URL: http://www.lubrizol.com/ViscosityModifiers/Asteric/default.html, XP003030374 | - KYUNG-YOUL BAEK ET AL, "Core-Functionalized Star Polymers by Transition Metal-Catalyzed Living Radical Polymerization. 1. Synthesis and Characterization of Star Polymers with PMMA Arms and Amide Cores", MACROMOLECULES, (2001), vol. 34, pages 7629 - 7635, XP003030375 DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1021/MA010973Z | Opposition | US4077893 | US5552491 | US5955405 | US6369162 | US2004106732 | WO2004087850 | US2006189490 | EP1833868 | - J. CHIEFARI et al., "LIVING FREE-RADICAL POLYMERIZATION BY REVERSIBLE ADDITION-FRAGMENTATION CHAIN TRANSFER: THE RAFT PROCESS", Macromolecules, (19980000), vol. 31, no. 16, pages 5559 - 5562, XP000771996 DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1021/ma9804951 | - Leonie Barner and Sébastien Perrier, "Polymers with Well-Defined End Groups via RAFT", Leonie Barner and Sébastien Perrier, Christopher Barner-Kowollik, Handbook of RAFT Polymerization, Wiley-VCH, pages 455 - 456, ISBN 9783527319244, XP003030853 | - "Asteric Viscosity Modifiers - Breakthrough VM Technology for High Viscosity Index (VI) Lubricants", The Lubrizol Corporation, (20120000), pages 1 - 2, URL: https://www.lubrizol.com/ViscosityModifiers/Asteric/default.html, XP055268043 | - H.T. LORD et al., "Microgel stars viaReversible Addition Fragmentation Chain Transfer (RAFT) polymerisation — a facile route to macroporous membranes, honeycomb patterned thin films and inverse opal substrates", J. Mater. Chem., (20030000), vol. 13, no. 11, pages 2819 - 2824, XP055268048 DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/B304208C |