Deutsch English Français

Contact

EP2102568

European procedure

Quick help

Maintenance news

Scheduled maintenance

Regular maintenance outages:
between 05.00 and 05.15 hrs CET (Monday to Sunday).

Other outages
Availability
Register Forum

2022.02.11

More...

News flashes

News flashes

New version of the European Patent Register - SPC information for Unitary Patents.

2024-03-06

More...

Extract from the Register of European Patents

EP About this file: EP2102568

EP2102568 - AIR-CONDITIONING ALGORITHM FOR WATER TERMINAL FREE COOLING [Right-click to bookmark this link]
Status	Patent revoked Status updated on 02.04.2022 Database last updated on 19.07.2024
Most recent event Tooltip	02.04.2022	Revocation of patent	published on 04.05.2022 [2022/18]
	02.04.2022	New entry: Despatch of communication that patent is revoked
Applicant(s)	For all designated states Carrier Corporation One Carrier Place Farmington, CT 06034 / US
	[2016/09]
Former [2009/39]	For all designated states Carrier Corporation One Carrier Place Farmington CT 06034 / US
Inventor(s)	01 / JOSSERAND, Olivier RN 1526, 3 Le Plantieu F-01120 La Boisse / FR
	02 / ROYET, Eric 324 rue du Canal F-01120 Thil / FR
	03 / GOUX, JeanPhilippe 17 chemin des Violettes F-69780 Toussieu / FR
	04 / RENAULT, Patrick 218 Gd rue de la Guillotière Lyon 69007 / FR
	[2016/09]
Former [2009/48]	01 / JOSSERAND, Olivier RN 1526, 3 Le Plantieu F-01120 La Boisse / FR
	02 / ROYET, Eric 324 rue du Canal F-01120 Thil / FR
	03 / GOUX, JeanPhilippe 17 chemin des Violettes F-69780 Toussieu / FR
	04 / RENAULT, Patrick 218 Gd rue de la Guillotiére Lyon 69007 / FR
Former [2009/43]	01 / JOSSERAND, Olivier RN 1526, 3 Le Plantieu F-01120 La Boisse / FR
	02 / ROYET, Eric 324 rue du Canal F-01120 Thil / FR
	03 / GOUX, JeanPhilippe 17 chemin des Violettes F-69780 Toussieu / FR
	04 / RENAULT, Patrick .218 Gd rue de la Guillotiére Lyon 69007 / FR
Former [2009/39]	01 / JOSSERAND, Olivier RN 1526, 3 Le Plantieu F-01120 La Boisse / FR
	02 / ROYET, Eric 324 rue du Canal F-01120 Thil / FR
	03 / GOUX, JeanPhilippe 17 chemin des Violettes F-69780 Toussieu / FR
	04 / RENAULT, Patrick . . / FR
Representative(s)	Dehns St. Bride's House 10 Salisbury Square London EC4Y 8JD / GB
	[N/P]
Former [2016/09]	Taylor, Adam David Dehns St Bride's House 10 Salisbury Square London EC4Y 8JD / GB
Former [2012/16]	Taylor, Adam David Dehns St. Bride's House 10 Salisbury Square London EC4Y 8JD / GB
Former [2009/39]	Leckey, David Herbert Frank B. Dehn & Co. St Bride's House 10 Salisbury Square London EC4Y 8JD / GB
Application number, filing date	06850040.4	29.12.2006
	[2009/39]
	WO2006US49628
Filing language	EN
Procedural language	EN
Publication	Type:	A1 Application with search report
	No.:	WO2008082398
	Date:	10.07.2008
	Language:	EN
	[2008/28]
	Type:	A1 Application with search report
	No.:	EP2102568
	Date:	23.09.2009
	Language:	EN
	The application published by WIPO in one of the EPO official languages on 10.07.2008 takes the place of the publication of the European patent application.
	[2009/39]
	Type:	B1 Patent specification
	No.:	EP2102568
	Date:	02.03.2016
	Language:	EN
	[2016/09]
Search report(s)	International search report - published on:	US	10.07.2008
	(Supplementary) European search report - dispatched on:	EP	24.01.2012
Classification	IPC:	F24F11/30, F24F110/10, F24F110/70, F24F11/00	[2018/49]
	CPC:	F24F11/30 (EP,US); F24F11/46 (EP,US); F24F11/63 (EP,US); F24F11/81 (EP,US); F24F11/84 (EP,US); F24F11/77 (EP,US); (+) F24F2011/0006 (EP,US); F24F2110/10 (EP,US); F24F2110/70 (EP,US); F24F2120/00 (EP,US); Y02B30/54 (EP,US); Y02B30/70 (EP) (-)
	Former IPC [2012/08]	F25D17/00, F24F11/00
	Former IPC [2009/39]	F25D17/00
Designated contracting states	AT, BE, BG, CH, CY, CZ, DE, DK, EE, ES, FI, FR, GB, GR, HU, IE, IS, IT, LI, LT, LU, LV, MC, NL, PL, PT, RO, SE, SI, SK, TR [2016/09]
Former [2009/39]	AT, BE, BG, CH, CY, CZ, DE, DK, EE, ES, FI, FR, GB, GR, HU, IE, IS, IT, LI, LT, LU, LV, MC, NL, PL, PT, RO, SE, SI, SK, TR
Title	German:	LUFTKLIMATISIERUNGSALGORITHMUS FÜR WASSERTERMINALFREIKÜHLUNG	[2009/39]
	English:	AIR-CONDITIONING ALGORITHM FOR WATER TERMINAL FREE COOLING	[2009/39]
	French:	ALGORITHME DE CLIMATISATION POUR REFROIDISSEMENT LIBRE DE TERMINAL D'EAU	[2009/39]
Entry into regional phase	24.07.2009	National basic fee paid
	24.07.2009	Search fee paid
	24.07.2009	Designation fee(s) paid
	24.07.2009	Examination fee paid
Examination procedure	24.07.2009	Examination requested [2009/39]
	16.08.2012	Amendment by applicant (claims and/or description)
	19.10.2012	Despatch of a communication from the examining division (Time limit: M04)
	14.01.2013	Reply to a communication from the examining division
	23.07.2015	Communication of intention to grant the patent
	02.12.2015	Fee for grant paid
	02.12.2015	Fee for publishing/printing paid
	02.12.2015	Receipt of the translation of the claim(s)
Divisional application(s)	The date of the Examining Division's first communication in respect of the earliest application for which a communication has been issued is 19.10.2012
Opposition(s)	Opponent(s)	01 02.12.2016 07.12.2016 ADMISSIBLE Siemens Schweiz AG Freilagerstrasse 40 8047 Zürich / CH Opponent's representative Maier, Daniel Oliver Siemens AG Postfach 22 16 34 80506 München / DE
		[N/P]
	Former [2017/02]
	Opponent(s)	01 02.12.2016 07.12.2016 ADMISSIBLE Siemens Schweiz AG Freilagerstrasse 40 8047 Zürich / CH Opponent's representative Maier, Daniel Oliver Siemens AG Postfach 22 16 34 80506 München / DE
	07.02.2017	Invitation to proprietor to file observations on the notice of opposition
	16.06.2017	Reply of patent proprietor to notice(s) of opposition
	25.10.2018	Date of oral proceedings
	07.01.2019	Despatch of interlocutory decision in opposition
	07.01.2019	Despatch of minutes of oral proceedings
	20.01.2022	Legal effect of revocation of patent [2022/18]
	31.03.2022	Despatch of communication that the patent will be revoked
Appeal following opposition	18.03.2019	Appeal received No. T0794/19
	17.05.2019	Statement of grounds filed
	20.01.2022	Result of appeal procedure: revocation of the patent
	31.03.2022	Despatch of the decision of the Board of Appeal
	15.03.2019	Appeal received No. T0794/19
	17.05.2019	Statement of grounds filed
	20.01.2022	Result of appeal procedure: revocation of the patent
	31.03.2022	Despatch of the decision of the Board of Appeal
	20.01.2022	Date of oral proceedings
Fees paid	Renewal fee
	24.07.2009	Renewal fee patent year 03
	23.12.2009	Renewal fee patent year 04
	28.12.2010	Renewal fee patent year 05
	12.12.2011	Renewal fee patent year 06
	11.12.2012	Renewal fee patent year 07
	12.12.2013	Renewal fee patent year 08
	11.12.2014	Renewal fee patent year 09
	23.12.2015	Renewal fee patent year 10
Opt-out from the exclusive Tooltip competence of the Unified Patent Court	See the Register of the Unified Patent Court for opt-out data
	Responsibility for the accuracy, completeness or quality of the data displayed under the link provided lies entirely with the Unified Patent Court.
Lapses during opposition Tooltip	HU	29.12.2006
	AT	02.03.2016
	BE	02.03.2016
	CY	02.03.2016
	CZ	02.03.2016
	DK	02.03.2016
	EE	02.03.2016
	FI	02.03.2016
	IT	02.03.2016
	LT	02.03.2016
	LV	02.03.2016
	MC	02.03.2016
	PL	02.03.2016
	RO	02.03.2016
	SE	02.03.2016
	SI	02.03.2016
	SK	02.03.2016
	TR	02.03.2016
	BG	02.06.2016
	GR	03.06.2016
	IS	02.07.2016
	PT	04.07.2016
	IE	29.12.2016
	LU	29.12.2016
	CH	31.12.2016
	LI	31.12.2016
	[2018/29]
Former [2018/28]	HU	29.12.2006
	AT	02.03.2016
	BE	02.03.2016
	CY	02.03.2016
	CZ	02.03.2016
	DK	02.03.2016
	EE	02.03.2016
	FI	02.03.2016
	IT	02.03.2016
	LT	02.03.2016
	LV	02.03.2016
	MC	02.03.2016
	PL	02.03.2016
	RO	02.03.2016
	SE	02.03.2016
	SI	02.03.2016
	SK	02.03.2016
	BG	02.06.2016
	GR	03.06.2016
	IS	02.07.2016
	PT	04.07.2016
	IE	29.12.2016
	LU	29.12.2016
	CH	31.12.2016
	LI	31.12.2016
Former [2017/49]	AT	02.03.2016
	BE	02.03.2016
	CZ	02.03.2016
	DK	02.03.2016
	EE	02.03.2016
	FI	02.03.2016
	IT	02.03.2016
	LT	02.03.2016
	LV	02.03.2016
	MC	02.03.2016
	PL	02.03.2016
	RO	02.03.2016
	SE	02.03.2016
	SI	02.03.2016
	SK	02.03.2016
	BG	02.06.2016
	GR	03.06.2016
	IS	02.07.2016
	PT	04.07.2016
	IE	29.12.2016
	LU	29.12.2016
	CH	31.12.2016
	LI	31.12.2016
Former [2017/47]	AT	02.03.2016
	BE	02.03.2016
	CZ	02.03.2016
	DK	02.03.2016
	EE	02.03.2016
	FI	02.03.2016
	IT	02.03.2016
	LT	02.03.2016
	LV	02.03.2016
	MC	02.03.2016
	PL	02.03.2016
	RO	02.03.2016
	SE	02.03.2016
	SI	02.03.2016
	SK	02.03.2016
	BG	02.06.2016
	GR	03.06.2016
	IS	02.07.2016
	PT	04.07.2016
Former [2017/13]	AT	02.03.2016
	BE	02.03.2016
	CZ	02.03.2016
	DK	02.03.2016
	EE	02.03.2016
	FI	02.03.2016
	IT	02.03.2016
	LT	02.03.2016
	LV	02.03.2016
	PL	02.03.2016
	RO	02.03.2016
	SE	02.03.2016
	SI	02.03.2016
	SK	02.03.2016
	BG	02.06.2016
	GR	03.06.2016
	IS	02.07.2016
	PT	04.07.2016
Former [2017/07]	AT	02.03.2016
	BE	02.03.2016
	CZ	02.03.2016
	DK	02.03.2016
	EE	02.03.2016
	FI	02.03.2016
	IT	02.03.2016
	LT	02.03.2016
	LV	02.03.2016
	PL	02.03.2016
	RO	02.03.2016
	SE	02.03.2016
	SK	02.03.2016
	GR	03.06.2016
	IS	02.07.2016
	PT	04.07.2016
Former [2017/03]	AT	02.03.2016
	BE	02.03.2016
	CZ	02.03.2016
	EE	02.03.2016
	FI	02.03.2016
	IT	02.03.2016
	LT	02.03.2016
	LV	02.03.2016
	PL	02.03.2016
	RO	02.03.2016
	SE	02.03.2016
	SK	02.03.2016
	GR	03.06.2016
	IS	02.07.2016
	PT	04.07.2016
Former [2016/51]	AT	02.03.2016
	CZ	02.03.2016
	EE	02.03.2016
	FI	02.03.2016
	LT	02.03.2016
	LV	02.03.2016
	PL	02.03.2016
	RO	02.03.2016
	SE	02.03.2016
	SK	02.03.2016
	GR	03.06.2016
	IS	02.07.2016
	PT	04.07.2016
Former [2016/50]	AT	02.03.2016
	CZ	02.03.2016
	EE	02.03.2016
	FI	02.03.2016
	LT	02.03.2016
	LV	02.03.2016
	PL	02.03.2016
	RO	02.03.2016
	SE	02.03.2016
	SK	02.03.2016
	GR	03.06.2016
	IS	02.07.2016
Former [2016/49]	AT	02.03.2016
	EE	02.03.2016
	FI	02.03.2016
	LT	02.03.2016
	LV	02.03.2016
	PL	02.03.2016
	SE	02.03.2016
	GR	03.06.2016
	IS	02.07.2016
Former [2016/48]	AT	02.03.2016
	FI	02.03.2016
	LT	02.03.2016
	LV	02.03.2016
	PL	02.03.2016
	SE	02.03.2016
	GR	03.06.2016
	IS	02.07.2016
Former [2016/39]	AT	02.03.2016
	FI	02.03.2016
	LT	02.03.2016
	LV	02.03.2016
	PL	02.03.2016
	SE	02.03.2016
	GR	03.06.2016
Former [2016/36]	AT	02.03.2016
	FI	02.03.2016
	LT	02.03.2016
	PL	02.03.2016
	GR	03.06.2016
Former [2016/35]	FI	02.03.2016
	GR	03.06.2016
Documents cited:	Search	[XI]US4244517 (STANKE DENNIS A, et al) [X] 1,3 * abstract * * column 4, line 31 - line 41 * [I] 2;
		[XI]US4830274 (JOHNSON TEDD P [US], et al) [X] 1 * column 3, line 3 - line 7; figure 1 * * abstract * [I] 2,3;
		[A]WO9010180 (VADELAS PTY LTD [AU]) [A] 5 * abstract *;
		[Y]US5025638 (YAMAGISHI KATSUAKI [JP], et al) [Y] 4 * column 6, line 57 - column 7, line 4 *;
		[XI]GB2258744 (CARRIER CORP [US]) [X] 1,3 * paragraph [0003] * * page 4, paragraphs 2,5; figures 1,2 * [I] 2,5-15;
		[XYI]EP0632234 (CARRIER CORP [US]) [X] 1-3 * abstract * * column 3, line 25 - line 35 * * column 13, line 5 - line 11 * [Y] 4 [I] 5-15;
		[A]US5707005 (KETTLER JOHN P [US], et al) [A] 1-15* the whole document *;
		[A]EP1004828 (DELPHI TECH INC [US]) [A] 4 * abstract *
	International search	[X]US6634422 (RAYBURN RONALD RICHARD [US], et al);
		[Y]US2004148950 (CATZEL PINCUS [ZA])
	by applicant	EP0632234
	Opposition	US4244517
		US4253153
		US4830274
		WO9010180
		US5025638
		GB2258744
		US5337574
		EP0632234
		US5404934
		US5707005
		US5976010
		EP1004828
		US2005028970
		US2006185373
		- "Das Regelungssymbol NIPU (Nightpurge)", EXCEL 500, Honeywell-CARE, BI 2. 1, (19921000), pages 14-1 - 14-4, XP055341537
		- "7.5.4. Luftqualität und Personen-präsenz", Steuern und Regeln in der Heizungs- und Lüftungstechnik, Impulsprogramm Haustechnik, 2., (19870501), pages 166 - 169, XP055341236
		- Hermann Recknagel, Eberhard Sprenger, Ernst-Rudolf Schramek, Taschenbuch für Heizung und Klimatechnik 2003. Einschließlich Warmwasser- und Kältetechnik, Oldenbourg, vol. 03/04, pages 1154 - 1157, 1174-1179, ISBN 3-486-26534-2, XP055341246

The EPO accepts no responsibility for the accuracy of data originating from other authorities; in particular, it does not guarantee that it is complete, up to date or fit for specific purposes.

Legal notice
Terms of use
24.1.24; 35p